The Quote


Read the new New Yorker piece on Phillip Pullman, if you need to gear up for heading back to class this week.
Pullman makes a case for the “literary School of Morals,” the ambiguous, dynamic democratic conversation that contradicts “theocracy” which he defines as “the tendency of human beings to gather power to themselves in the name of something that may not be questioned.” Pullman claims that theocratic impulses will eventually “defeat” the literary School of Morals, but that we should just plug along anyway, acting as if literary work can make a difference:
“I think we should act as if. I think we should read books, and tell children stories, and take them to the theatre, and learn poems and make music, as if it would make a difference…We should act as if the universe were listening to us and responding. We should act as if life were going to win.”

Pullman’s words are a good shot in the arm for me as I head back into second semester with the sixers. I’ve spent the day editing drafts. They're not the greatest, but they're all I've got right now so I’m practicing acting as if.
This is the penultimate day of vacation and Husbandman and I are heading out to the basketball game. Go Hoosiers!

Comments

Undomestic said…
I loved going to the games. I was there with Calbert Cheney, Alan Henderson and the rest of the crew. Even though we were up in the nosebleed seats, it was so much fun!!!! Go Hoosiers!!!
LH said…
c, those were great years. i still miss calbert. We were at the games at the same time. Wild!
we beat michigan tonight in a handy victory. Go IU. Fight fight fight.
Undomestic said…
Yeah!!! My husband graduated from Michigan, and he loves to point out how Michigan is always above IU in those Newsweek lists. At least I can claim victory this time...because you know, in the Big 10, basketball trumps all else.
Anonymous said…
Great Pullman quote and interesting article. I loved that he mentioned the Mrs. Bates scene in Austen. I have always found that scene strangely powerful. It did get me thinking about how most religious texts are in essence stories and contain those literary ambiguities. The story of Job for example which is often ignored leaves you with the uncomfortable message that bad things do happen to good people.
I do think Pullman is wrong about Tolkien though.
KC said…
as you may recall, i get the new yorker, and yet i never read it. this causes a lot of guilt.

i am going to investigate podcasts of the ny articles, as i'm currently obsessed with my new mp3 player.

however, podcast or no podcast, i will read this one.

your blog has been quite literary over break. i think you may have been thinking too hard.
LH said…
Hi Cari, I didn't know M went to Michigan. They were not up to the task last night. That should be good for some fine taunting.

K, Have you read the Golden Compass? Q. good. I only read the first one, but it's a great read. Pullman was tough on Tolkien, you're right. I've never read that series, but we have some fans here in the house. It was Tolkien's birthday yesterday, btw. Writer's Almanac told me that. I liked his comments about the avoidance of adulthood in children's books.

kace, i'm jealous of your mp3. i better start saving the pennies. I have been reading a lot during this break. If i didn't have to work, i would turn my livingroom into a literary salon, ala Gertrude Stein. Awesome idea, yes???
Tom Hilton said…
I'm about halfway through the Pullman profile, and it's a great piece--and yes, I loved that quote as well. I admire people who, like Pullman, can clearly and simply articulate fundamental principles of human decency.

Kateg, I too find the Miss Bates scene very powerful; I have a nearly physical reaction to it, and it always makes me think of all the times I have been less than kind to people in my own life.
Anonymous said…
I love the whole Dark Materials series. Read The Subtle Knife; it's the best one. And if you enjoy that sort of thing, listen to it instead. Read by a cast of chararacters, it had me driving around the block instead of turning off the car.
Anonymous said…
Tom: Just had to say yes! My first reaction to that scene was to laugh, because what Emme says is on point and witty. And then to so clearly "feel" the reaction of the muddling but sweet Mrs. Bates. Wow.. the guilt comes flooding in. Now that is writing.
Lh: I never read Pullman. National Theatre in London was doing His Dark Materials and some friends of mine loved it. Re Childrens books, have you read Dark is Rising Series by Susan Cooper? I loved that series.
LH said…
At our house we have taken up the lines from the movie version of that scene where Emma is chided with "Poorly Done, Emma!" "Poorly done!" is used pretty frequently.

t, i like your blog, thanks for visiting.

Haven't read Susan Cooper, Kate, but i know of her. i have friends who are big fans.

jdoc, peter agrees about subtle knife. may have to get the cd's. could get me back on the treadmill?

Popular Posts